Systems of psychotherapy
Every school gets the same treatment: what it says about personality, what it says goes wrong, how it says change happens, what it actually looks like in a room, what the evidence supports, and what its critics get right.
Psychoanalytic
Psychodynamic
Psychodynamic Therapies
1911 – present
Keep the insight, drop the couch: the relationship is the laboratory, and time is limited.
Good supportCore surveySession scriptAdlerian Therapy (Individual Psychology)
1912 – present
Behaviour is not pushed by the past; it is pulled by a goal the person has not admitted to having.
Limited evidenceAnalytical Psychology (Jungian)
1913 – present
The psyche is self-regulating and purposive. The symptom is the psyche attempting a correction.
Limited evidenceObject Relations Theory
1930s – present
We are not driven toward pleasure. We are driven toward people — and we carry them inside.
Mixed findingsSelf Psychology
1971 – present
What looks like grandiosity is usually a self that never got the responses it needed to cohere.
Limited evidenceRelational Psychoanalysis
1980s – present
There are two people in the room, and neither of them is objective.
Mixed findingsMentalization-Based Treatment
1990s – present
Not insight. The recovery of the capacity to hold minds in mind, in the moment it collapses.
Good supportTransference-Focused Psychotherapy
1980s – present
The split internal world arrives in the room. Interpret it there, inside a contract that holds.
Good supportIntensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy
1970s – present
Go directly at the defense until the warded-off feeling arrives. And watch the anxiety.
Good support
Humanistic
Person-Centered Therapies
1940 – present
The client knows what hurts and where to go; the therapist provides the conditions in which they can find out.
Good supportCore surveySession scriptMotivational Interviewing
1983 – present
People are persuaded more by what they hear themselves say than by what they are told.
Strong & replicatedCore surveySession script
Experiential
Gestalt Therapy
1951 – present
Lose your mind and come to your senses. What is happening now, in this room, in your body?
Promising / emergingCore surveyEmotion-Focused Therapy
1980s – present
You cannot leave a place until you have arrived at it. Emotion is changed by emotion, not by reason.
Good supportCore survey
Existential
Interpersonal
Interpersonal Theory & Reconstructive Therapy
1940s – present
Personality is not inside you. It is the pattern of what happens between you and other people, repeatedly.
Good supportCore surveyInterpersonal Psychotherapy
1970s – present
Depression is a medical illness that happens in an interpersonal context. Change the context.
Strong & replicatedCore surveySession scriptGroup Psychotherapy
1900s – present
The group is a social microcosm. Whatever a person does out there, they will eventually do in here.
Strong & replicatedCore survey
Behavioral
Exposure Therapies
1920s – present
The only way out is through. Avoidance is what keeps fear alive, so the treatment is to stop avoiding.
Strong & replicatedCore surveySession scriptBehavior Therapies
1913 – present
Behaviour is selected by its consequences. Change the consequences and you change the behaviour.
Strong & replicatedCore surveyEye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing
1987 – present
It works. The argument is entirely about why — and the eye movements may not be the reason.
Strong & replicatedCore survey
Cognitive
Cognitive Therapy
1955 – present
It is not events themselves but the meaning we give them that disturbs us.
Strong & replicatedCore surveySession scriptRational Emotive Behavior Therapy
1955 – present
You are not disturbed by things, but by the rigid demands you place on them.
Good supportSchema Therapy
1990 – present
For the patients cognitive therapy could not reach: go to the childhood origin, and reparent within limits.
Good supportMetacognitive Therapy
1990s – present
It is not what you think. It is how long you think about it, and why you believe you have to.
Good support
Third wave / contextual
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy
1980s – present
The problem is not the pain. The problem is the struggle against the pain, and what that struggle costs you.
Good supportCore surveySession scriptDialectical Behavior Therapy
1980s – present
You are doing the best you can, and you have to do better. Both are true.
Strong & replicatedCore surveySession scriptCompassion-Focused Therapy
2000s – present
For people who know the alternative thought is true and still feel worthless.
Promising / emergingMindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy
1979 – present
Not feeling better, but getting better at being with what is — and noticing the slide before it becomes a fall.
Strong & replicatedCore survey
Systemic & relational
Constructivist & narrative
Positive Psychology & Well-Being Therapies
1998 – present
The absence of depression is not the presence of a life. Build the positive as well as removing the negative.
Promising / emergingCore surveySolution-Focused Brief Therapy
1980s – present
You do not have to understand a problem to solve it. Find what already works and do more of it.
Promising / emergingCore surveyNarrative Therapy
1980s – present
The person is not the problem. The problem is the problem.
Limited evidencePersonal Construct Psychology
1955 – present
Every person is a scientist, testing personal theories about the world. Some theories are not being tested.
Limited evidence
Sociocultural & justice-oriented
Gender-Informed Therapies
1970s – present
The personal is political. Some of what arrives as private pathology is a social arrangement, felt from inside.
Mixed findingsCore surveyMulticultural Therapies
1960s – present
There is no culture-free therapy. There is only therapy whose culture has been made explicit, and therapy whose has not.
Good supportCore surveySession script
Somatic & body-based
Altered states & adjunctive
Clinical Hypnosis & Hypnotherapy
1770s – present
Not a treatment in itself. A state in which other treatments may work better.
Good supportPsychedelic-Assisted Psychotherapy
1950s–1970, 1990s–present
The drug does not do the therapy. It opens a window, and what happens in that window is the treatment.
Promising / emergingCore surveyMDMA-Assisted Psychotherapy
1970s–1985, 2000–present
A window in which the trauma can be approached without being overwhelmed by it — or avoided.
ContestedCore surveyKetamine-Assisted Psychotherapy
2000 – present
The only compound in this family already in routine clinical use — and the one where the psychotherapy is most often left out.
Mixed findings
Integrative
Integrative Therapies
1930s – present
No single system is adequate to every patient. The question is how to combine them without incoherence.
Good supportCore surveyThe Unified Protocol
2000s – present
One protocol for all the emotional disorders, because they share a mechanism.
Good supportDigital & Low-Intensity Therapies
1990s – present
The question is no longer whether it works, but how little human contact it can survive.
Strong & replicated